It took the Shake Shack years before it introduced a second burger on its menu aside from its signature Shackburger. When it hit the boards, the Smoke Shack was a near instant hit (we sure loved it). It took the signature well-seared Shake Shack patty and paired it with crisp bacon and a sweet-hot pickled pepper relish.
It's a flavor combination worth repeating as often as possible, so I decided to take my own spin on it to the backyard burger.
The basic flavors are the same—burger, relish, bacon—but I found that a plain old cherry pepper relish with sliced bacon on top didn't quite match up to the more robust flavors of a thicker, grilled burger the way it did for the smaller griddled Shack burgers. To up the flavor, I instead used a bacon and cherry pepper relish I initially developed as a pizza topping. The smoky bacon flavor is built right into the relish, so it coats the burger more evenly.
Other than that, things are fairly standard here—crisp bacon slices (which I pre-cook in the oven—you can also use fatter slab bacon and slow-cook it on the grill before you start grilling your burgers), sliced American cheese (cheddar would also work here), and a fat slice of grilled onion, just to make the whole thing healthy.
Get The Recipe
More Burger Toppings!
- Grilled Cuban Fritas (Spiced Burgers with Shoestring Fries)
- Burgers with Creamy Feta Sauce and Tomato-Cucumber Relish »
- Pepperoni Garlic Bread Burgers
- Poutine Burgers
- Muffuletta Burgers
- Barbecue Bacon Burgers
- Korean Barbecue Kim-Cheese Burgers
- Quadruple Chili Cheeseburgers
- Hot Hawaiian Burgers
All products linked here have been independently selected by our editors. We may earn a commission on purchases, as described in our affiliate policy.